The utility analysis in the above examination problem is the two commodity consumer equilibrium condition or law of equi-marginal utility. The condition for two commodity consumer equilibrium is,
Marginal utility of last rupee spent on commodity X \(\left( \frac { M{ U }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ x } } \right) \)= Marginal utility of last rupee spent on commodity Y\(\left( \frac { M{ U }_{ y } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right) \)
In the above examination problem, MU_x = 5, P_x = 4, then
\(\left( \frac { M{ U }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ x } } \right) \) =\(\frac{5}{4}\)=1.25
MU_y = 4, P_y = 5, then
\(\left( \frac { M{ U }_{ y } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right) \) =\(\frac{4}{5}\) =0.8
The above example gives inequality as,
\(\left( \frac { M{ U }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ x } } \right) >\left( \frac { M{ U }_{ y } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right) \)
It means, marginal utility from the last rupee spent on commodity X is more than marginal utility from the last rupee spent on commodity Y. So, to attain the equilibrium consumer must increase the quantity of X, which decrease the MUx and decrease the quantity of Y which will increase the MUy. Increase in quantity of X and decrease in quantity of Y continue till \(\left( \frac { M{ U }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ x } } \right) =\left( \frac { M{ U }_{ y } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right) \)

The equilibrium condition for a rational consumer is
Marginal rate of substitution (MRS _x,y ) = Market rate of exchange (MREx,y=\(\frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \))
2=\(\frac{2}{2}\) \(\therefore\) 2 \(\neq\) 1
The above example gives inequality, as
MRS_x,y(2) > MRE_x,y(1) \(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] .\)
(a) It means that to obtain one more unit of X, the consumer is willing to sacrifice more unit of Y as compared to what is required in the market.
(b) In other words, conusmer's willingness to pay for commodity X is higher than what market values for commodity X.
(c) This induces the consumer to buy more of X and less of Y, which result in fall in MRS till it become equal to price.

(a) When purchasing a unit of a commodity a consumer compares its price with the expected utility from it. Utility obtained is the benefit, and the price payable is the cost. The consumer compares benefit and the cost. He will buy the unit of a commodity only if the benefit is greater than or at least equal to the cost.
(b) equilibrium Conditions for Single Commo ·ty Consumer Equilibrium Necessary Condition Marginal utility in terms of Money = Price
\(\frac { Marginal\ utility\ of\ a\ product\ in\ utils[M{ U }_{ X }] }{ \ utility\ of\ one\ rupee[M{ U }_{ M }] } \)
In particular, the condition (A) says that the marginal utility of a Product in terms of Money be equal to its price. Sometimes, this is loosely stated as marginal utility is equal to price, i.e.,

(b) Suppose, the price of commodity X in the market is Rs.3 per unit. It means he has to pay Rs.3 per unit for all the units he buys. Suppose, the utility obtained from the first unit is 5 utils (=Rs. 5). The consumer will buy this unit because the utility of this unit is greater than the price and this process continues till Marginal utility = Price as shown in the above schedule at quantity 3.
(c) Consumer will not buy the fourth unit MU = Price.
If MU> PRICE
(a) Means benefit is greater than cost and whenever benefit is greater than cost, consumer keeps on consuming additional unit of a commodity till MU = Price.
(b) It is so because according to the law of diminishing marginal utility, MUfalls as more is purchased till it becomes equal to price.
If MU< PRICE
(a) Means benefit is less than cost and whenever benefit is less than cost, the consumer keeps on decreasing additional unit of a commodity till MU = Price.
(b) It is so because according to the law of diminishing marginal utility, MU rises as less units are consumed till it becomes equal to price.
Sufficient Condition
Total gain falls as more is purchased after equilibrium. It means that consumer continues to purchase so long as total gain is increasing or at least constant.
(a) It can be explained with the help of the following schedule:
because utility of this unit is 2 utils (= Rs.2) which is less than the price. It is not worth buying the fourth unit. The consumer will restrict his purchase to only 3 units

(i) To define consumer equilibrium, we use Indifference Curve map and the budget line.
Two Conditions Cor Consumer Equilibrium
(a) Necessary Condition
Marginal Rate of Substitution Market Rate of Exchange \(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
Or MRS _x,y =\(\frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \)
(Market Rate of Exchange) MRE
Or MRS _x,y =MRE\(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
If MRS _x,y>MRE\(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
(a) It means that to obtain one more unit of X, the consumer is willing to sacrifice more unit of Y as compared to what is required in the market.
(b) In other words, consumers willingness to pay for commodity X is higher than what market values for commodity X.
(c) This induces the consumer to buy more of X and less of Y, which result in fall in MRS till it become equal to price.
(ii) If MRS _x,y< MRE\(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
(a) It means that to obtain one more unit of X, the consumer is willing to sacrifice less unit of Y as compared to what is required in the market.
(b) In other words, consumer's willingness to pay for commodity X is lower than what market values for commodity X.
(c) This induces the consumer to buy less of X and more of Y, which result in rise in MRS till it become equal to price.

(b) Sufficient Condition MRS Diminishing (Convex) at X, Y a point of equilibrium i.e., when MRS _x,y=MRE \(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
(ii) The consumer will reach equilibrium when the budget line is tangential to the higher possible Indifference Curve, i.e., where necessary and sufficient conditions satisfy. In the above diagram, the consumer will reach equilibrium at point E where budget line RS is tangential to the highest possible IC₂.
(iii) The consumer cannot move to Indifference Curve, i.e., IC₃ as this is beyond his money income.
(iv) Even on IC₂, all the other points except E are beyond his means.
(v) Hence, at point E, the consumer is in equilibrium where his satisfaction maximizes, given his income and prices of goods X and Y. In equilibrium at E, the slope of Budget line = the slope of Indifference, Therefore, MRS xy is eq to the ratio of the prices of two goods \(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)

(i) To define consumer equilibrium, we use Indifference Curve map and the budget line.
Two Conditions Cor Consumer Equilibrium
(a) Necessary Condition
Marginal Rate of Substitution Market Rate of Exchange \(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
Or MRS _x,y =\(\frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \)
(Market Rate of Exchange) MRE
Or MRS _x,y =MRE\(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
If MRS _x,y>MRE\(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
(a) It means that to obtain one more unit of X, the consumer is willing to sacrifice more unit of Y as compared to what is required in the market.
(b) In other words, consumers willingness to pay for commodity X is higher than what market values for commodity X.
(c) This induces the consumer to buy more of X and less of Y, which result in fall in MRS till it become equal to price.
(ii) If MRS _x,y< MRE\(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
(a) It means that to obtain one more unit of X, the consumer is willing to sacrifice less unit of Y as compared to what is required in the market.
(b) In other words, consumer's willingness to pay for commodity X is lower than what market values for commodity X.
(c) This induces the consumer to buy less of X and more of Y, which result in rise in MRS till it become equal to price.

(b) Sufficient Condition MRS Diminishing (Convex) at X, Y a point of equilibrium i.e., when MRS _x,y=MRE \(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
(ii) The consumer will reach equilibrium when the budget line is tangential to the higher possible Indifference Curve, i.e., where necessary and sufficient conditions satisfy. In the above diagram, the consumer will reach equilibrium at point E where budget line RS is tangential to the highest possible IC₂.
(iii) The consumer cannot move to Indifference Curve, i.e., IC₃ as this is beyond his money income.
(iv) Even on IC₂, all the other points except E are beyond his means.
(v) Hence, at point E, the consumer is in equilibrium where his satisfaction maximizes, given his income and prices of goods X and Y. In equilibrium at E, the slope of Budget line = the slope of Indifference, Therefore, MRS xy is eq to the ratio of the prices of two goods \(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)

(i) To define consumer equilibrium, we use Indifference Curve map and the budget line.
Two Conditions Cor Consumer Equilibrium
(a) Necessary Condition
Marginal Rate of Substitution Market Rate of Exchange \(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
Or MRS _x,y =\(\frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \)
(Market Rate of Exchange) MRE
Or MRS _x,y =MRE\(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
If MRS _x,y>MRE\(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
(a) It means that to obtain one more unit of X, the consumer is willing to sacrifice more unit of Y as compared to what is required in the market.
(b) In other words, consumers willingness to pay for commodity X is higher than what market values for commodity X.
(c) This induces the consumer to buy more of X and less of Y, which result in fall in MRS till it become equal to price.
(ii) If MRS _x,y< MRE\(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
(a) It means that to obtain one more unit of X, the consumer is willing to sacrifice less unit of Y as compared to what is required in the market.
(b) In other words, consumer's willingness to pay for commodity X is lower than what market values for commodity X.
(c) This induces the consumer to buy less of X and more of Y, which result in rise in MRS till it become equal to price.

(b) Sufficient Condition MRS Diminishing (Convex) at X, Y a point of equilibrium i.e., when MRS _x,y=MRE \(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
(ii) The consumer will reach equilibrium when the budget line is tangential to the higher possible Indifference Curve, i.e., where necessary and sufficient conditions satisfy. In the above diagram, the consumer will reach equilibrium at point E where budget line RS is tangential to the highest possible IC₂.
(iii) The consumer cannot move to Indifference Curve, i.e., IC₃ as this is beyond his money income.
(iv) Even on IC₂, all the other points except E are beyond his means.
(v) Hence, at point E, the consumer is in equilibrium where his satisfaction maximizes, given his income and prices of goods X and Y. In equilibrium at E, the slope of Budget line = the slope of Indifference, Therefore, MRS xy is eq to the ratio of the prices of two goods \(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)

(i) To define consumer equilibrium, we use Indifference Curve map and the budget line.
Two Conditions Cor Consumer Equilibrium
(a) Necessary Condition
Marginal Rate of Substitution Market Rate of Exchange \(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
Or MRS _x,y =\(\frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \)
(Market Rate of Exchange) MRE
Or MRS _x,y =MRE\(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
If MRS _x,y>MRE\(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
(a) It means that to obtain one more unit of X, the consumer is willing to sacrifice more unit of Y as compared to what is required in the market.
(b) In other words, consumers willingness to pay for commodity X is higher than what market values for commodity X.
(c) This induces the consumer to buy more of X and less of Y, which result in fall in MRS till it become equal to price.
(ii) If MRS _x,y< MRE\(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
(a) It means that to obtain one more unit of X, the consumer is willing to sacrifice less unit of Y as compared to what is required in the market.
(b) In other words, consumer's willingness to pay for commodity X is lower than what market values for commodity X.
(c) This induces the consumer to buy less of X and more of Y, which result in rise in MRS till it become equal to price.

(b) Sufficient Condition MRS Diminishing (Convex) at X, Y a point of equilibrium i.e., when MRS _x,y=MRE \(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
(ii) The consumer will reach equilibrium when the budget line is tangential to the higher possible Indifference Curve, i.e., where necessary and sufficient conditions satisfy. In the above diagram, the consumer will reach equilibrium at point E where budget line RS is tangential to the highest possible IC₂.
(iii) The consumer cannot move to Indifference Curve, i.e., IC₃ as this is beyond his money income.
(iv) Even on IC₂, all the other points except E are beyond his means.
(v) Hence, at point E, the consumer is in equilibrium where his satisfaction maximizes, given his income and prices of goods X and Y. In equilibrium at E, the slope of Budget line = the slope of Indifference, Therefore, MRS xy is eq to the ratio of the prices of two goods \(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)

(i) To define consumer equilibrium, we use Indifference Curve map and the budget line.
Two Conditions Cor Consumer Equilibrium
(a) Necessary Condition
Marginal Rate of Substitution Market Rate of Exchange \(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
Or MRS _x,y =\(\frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \)
(Market Rate of Exchange) MRE
Or MRS _x,y =MRE\(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
If MRS _x,y>MRE\(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
(a) It means that to obtain one more unit of X, the consumer is willing to sacrifice more unit of Y as compared to what is required in the market.
(b) In other words, consumers willingness to pay for commodity X is higher than what market values for commodity X.
(c) This induces the consumer to buy more of X and less of Y, which result in fall in MRS till it become equal to price.
(ii) If MRS _x,y< MRE\(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
(a) It means that to obtain one more unit of X, the consumer is willing to sacrifice less unit of Y as compared to what is required in the market.
(b) In other words, consumer's willingness to pay for commodity X is lower than what market values for commodity X.
(c) This induces the consumer to buy less of X and more of Y, which result in rise in MRS till it become equal to price.

(b) Sufficient Condition MRS Diminishing (Convex) at X, Y a point of equilibrium i.e., when MRS _x,y=MRE \(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)
(ii) The consumer will reach equilibrium when the budget line is tangential to the higher possible Indifference Curve, i.e., where necessary and sufficient conditions satisfy. In the above diagram, the consumer will reach equilibrium at point E where budget line RS is tangential to the highest possible IC₂.
(iii) The consumer cannot move to Indifference Curve, i.e., IC₃ as this is beyond his money income.
(iv) Even on IC₂, all the other points except E are beyond his means.
(v) Hence, at point E, the consumer is in equilibrium where his satisfaction maximizes, given his income and prices of goods X and Y. In equilibrium at E, the slope of Budget line = the slope of Indifference, Therefore, MRS xy is eq to the ratio of the prices of two goods \(\left[ \frac { { P }_{ x } }{ { P }_{ y } } \right] \)

(a) When purchasing a unit of a commodity a consumer compares its price with the expected utility from it. Utility obtained is the benefit, and the price payable is the cost. The consumer compares benefit and the cost. He will buy the unit of a commodity only if the benefit is greater than or at least equal to the cost.
(b) Equilibrium Conditions for Single Commodity Consumer Equilibrium
Necessary Condition
Marginal utility in terms of Money = Price     ...(A)
\(\frac { Marginal\ utility\ of\ a\ product\ in\ utils[M{ U }_{ X }] }{ Marginal\ utility\ of\ one\ rupee[M{ U }_{ M }] } =Price\)   ...(B)
In particular, the condition (A) says that the marginal utility of a Product in terms of Money be equal to its price. Sometimes, this is loosely stated as marginal utility is equal to price, i.e.,

(b) Suppose, the price of commodity X in the market is Rs.3 per unit. It means he has to pay Rs.3 per unit for all the units he buys. Suppose, the utility obtained from the first unit is 5 utils (=Rs. 5). The consumer will buy this unit because the utility of this unit is greater than the price and this process continues till Marginal utility = Price as shown in the above schedule at quantity 3.
(c) Consumer will not buy the fourth unit MU= Price.
 If MU> PRICE
(a) Means benefit is greater than cost and whenever benefit is greater than cost, consumer keeps on consuming additional unit of a commodity till MU = Price.
(b) It is so because according to the law of diminishing marginal utility, MU falls as more is purchased till it becomes equal to price.
 If MU< PRICE
(a) Means benefit is less than cost and whenever benefit is less than cost, the consumer keeps on decreasing additional unit of a commodity till MU = Price.
(b) It is so because according to the law of diminishing marginal utility, MU rises as less units are consumed till it becomes equal to price.
Sufficient Condition
Total gain falls as more is purchased after equilibrium. It means that consumer continues to purchase so long as total gain is increasing or at least constant.
(a) It can be explained with the help of the following schedule:
because utility of this unit is 2 utils (= Rs.2) which is less than the price. It is not worth buying the fourth unit. The consumer will restrict his purchase to only 3 units.